Ebook A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz
Make use of the innovative modern technology that human establishes today to locate guide A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz effortlessly. Yet first, we will certainly ask you, just how much do you love to check out a book A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz Does it always up until coating? Wherefore does that book check out? Well, if you really love reading, aim to review the A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz as one of your reading collection. If you just reviewed guide based on need at the time and incomplete, you need to attempt to such as reading A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz first.
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz
Ebook A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz
Is A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz book your preferred reading? Is fictions? Just how's concerning past history? Or is the very best vendor novel your choice to satisfy your extra time? Or even the politic or religious publications are you searching for currently? Here we go we offer A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz book collections that you need. Lots of varieties of books from numerous areas are provided. From fictions to science and also religious can be browsed and also figured out right here. You may not worry not to find your referred book to check out. This A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz is one of them.
If you desire actually obtain the book A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz to refer now, you should follow this web page constantly. Why? Keep in mind that you require the A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz resource that will offer you ideal expectation, don't you? By visiting this site, you have begun to make new deal to always be up-to-date. It is the first thing you could start to get all profit from remaining in a website with this A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz as well as other compilations.
From currently, finding the finished site that sells the finished publications will certainly be many, however we are the trusted website to go to. A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz with simple link, easy download, as well as completed book collections become our excellent services to get. You can find as well as make use of the benefits of selecting this A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz as every little thing you do. Life is consistently creating as well as you need some brand-new publication A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz to be referral always.
If you still need a lot more publications A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz as references, going to browse the title and style in this site is offered. You will find even more lots books A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz in various self-controls. You can also when possible to review the book that is currently downloaded. Open it and save A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz in your disk or gadget. It will ease you anywhere you require guide soft documents to check out. This A Century Of Genocide: Utopias Of Race And Nation, By Eric D. Weitz soft file to read can be reference for everyone to boost the skill as well as capacity.
Why did the twentieth century witness unprecedented organized genocide? Can we learn why genocide is perpetrated by comparing different cases of genocide? Is the Holocaust unique, or does it share causes and features with other cases of state-sponsored mass murder? Can genocide be prevented?
Blending gripping narrative with trenchant analysis, Eric Weitz investigates four of the twentieth century's major eruptions of genocide: the Soviet Union under Stalin, Nazi Germany, Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge, and the former Yugoslavia. Drawing on historical sources as well as trial records, memoirs, novels, and poems, Weitz explains the prevalence of genocide in the twentieth century--and shows how and why it became so systematic and deadly.
Weitz depicts the searing brutality of each genocide and traces its origins back to those most powerful categories of the modern world: race and nation. He demonstrates how, in each of the cases, a strong state pursuing utopia promoted a particular mix of extreme national and racial ideologies. In moments of intense crisis, these states targeted certain national and racial groups, believing that only the annihilation of these "enemies" would enable the dominant group to flourish. And in each instance, large segments of the population were enticed to join in the often ritualistic actions that destroyed their neighbors.
This book offers some of the most absorbing accounts ever written of the population purges forever associated with the names Stalin, Hitler, Pol Pot, and Milosevic. A controversial and richly textured comparison of these four modern cases, it identifies the social and political forces that produce genocide.
- Sales Rank: #840752 in Books
- Published on: 2005-01-23
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 1.00" h x 6.10" w x 9.10" l, 1.15 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 368 pages
From Publishers Weekly
University of Minnesota history professor Weitz offers a sobering comparative study of four of the past century's genocidal regimes: Stalin's Soviet Union, Nazi Germany, Cambodia under Pol Pot and Bosnia in the 1990s. (While acknowledging that the Holocaust was unprecedented, Weitz explicitly rejects the notion that it was "unique" and incomparable to other genocides.) Weitz begins with a tightly argued account of how Enlightenment thought, together with 19th-century romanticism's nostalgia for an imagined and innocent past, combined to provide the intellectual underpinning for the growth of nationalism and racism, which provided the 20th-century engine for state-organized genocide. Weitz then explores the historical precedents in each country, providing context for a comparison of how each government accomplished its horrific goals. There is much new in Weitz's analysis and his isolation of the common mechanisms of state-sponsored genocide is an invaluable contribution to the literature on the subject, such as his discussion of the prevalence of one-on-one brutality in the cases of Serbian, Nazi and Cambodian atrocities. The descriptions of the mechanisms for the purges, specifically how each government made large sections of their population complicit in the crimes, is chilling. Despite its analytical and reasoned approach, this work cannot be read without feeling outrage, despair and horror. Weitz's work raises profound questions about the human capacity for violence.
Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
One of Choice's Outstanding Academic Titles for 2003
"There is much new in Weitz's analysis and his isolation of the common mechanisms of state-sponsored genocide is an invaluable contribution to the literature on the subject. . . . Despite its analytical and reasoned approach, this work cannot be read without feeling outrage, despair and horror. Weitz's work raises profound questions about the human capacity for violence."--Publishers Weekly
"An important, thought-provoking book on an inordinately complex subject."--Gavriel Rosenfeld, The New Leader
"Weitz has produced something exceedingly rare: a scholarly book one cannot put down. This is a meritorious, thoughtful book."--Choice
"Weitz makes a persuasive case that these genocides were not simply anarchic eruptions of age-old hatreds, but rather were engineered by crisis-ridden regimes promoting utopian visions requiring a radical refashioning of the population."--Martin Farrell, Perspectives on Politics
"A Century of Genocide has much to offer. It will serve as an excellent first introduction to Lenin and Stalin's crimes, the Holocaust, the Cambodian massacres of the 1970s and the ethnic cleansing in Yugoslavia."--Brendon Simms, Times Higher Education Supplement
""A] book that must be read and that must be argued over. Without an understanding of the issues [it] tackle[s] with passion and in depth, the desire to intervene--to prevent ethnic cleansing or genocide--is meaningless."--Rima Berns-McGown, International Journal
"This important, highly thoughtful book is a welcome addition to the growing literature on genocide in the twentieth century. It deserves a wide audience among scholars, undergraduates, and policy makers. Broad ranging, genuinely comparative, rigorous, and learned, A Century of Genocide is engagingly written, while prudent and balanced in its judgments."--Frank Chalk, Slavic Review
From the Inside Flap
"In his well-documented comparative account of five mass killings in the twentieth century, Eric Weitz has uniquely perceived the ideological connections and analogous revolutionary crises that resulted in 'a century of genocide.' Not only does his book demonstrate that human rights safeguards are indispensable for preventing human rights disasters, but it will help identify early warnings of future crimes against humanity."--David Weissbrodt, David Weissbrodt, coauthor of International Human Rights and Member, United Nations Sub-Commission on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights
"This ambitious and broad-ranging study of genocide in the twentieth century is one of the most illuminating works of comparative history to appear in recent years. It shows in graphic and sometimes gut-wrenching detail how a vicious combination of racist ideology, power hungry leadership, and a popular willingness to participate in mass murder can result in the most appalling crimes against humanity. We can hope to prevent genocide only if we understand it, and this book is a major contribution to such an awareness."--George M. Fredrickson, author of Racism: A Short History
"This is a passionate, persuasive, and elegantly argued study of the genocidal policies and behavior of four twentieth-century regimes that are rarely systematically compared."--David Chandler, author of Brother Number One: A Political Biography of Pol Pot
"Weitz brings a wealth of learning and understanding to the problem of genocide. His book is sensible and even-handed all the way through, breaking free of staid categories of analysis. Innovative and refreshing in tone, it traces its devastating story right down to the local level, where, after all, genocide happens."--Robert Gellately, author of Backing Hitler: Consent and Coercion in Nazi Germany
"Eric Weitz's Century of Genocide is a model of comparative history. Brilliantly organized around the themes of race and nation, it keenly analyzes both the similarities and differences between the genocidal regimes of Hitler's Germany and Pol Pot's Cambodia and the genocidal actions of Stalin's Soviet Union and Milosevic's Greater Serbia."--Christopher Browning, author of Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland
Most helpful customer reviews
27 of 28 people found the following review helpful.
It lacks something
By pnotley@hotmail.com
Several years ago Eric Weitz wrote a fascinating book about the German Communist Party which argued that its notoriously truculent and dogmatic nature was not simply the result of Stalinist domination, but instead reflected the party's own German traditions as well as an understandable reaction to Weimar's intolerance of them. One would think that Weitz would be an excellent author to write about twentieth-century genocide. But this comparative account of four major genocides is disappointing. By his own admission Weitz does not have sufficient scholarly expertise to study the genocides in Armenia and Rwanda. So instead he looks first at Soviet terror in general and the more specifically genocidal deportations carried out against various nationalities during and after World War Two. Then he looks at Nazi Germany, Pol Pot Cambodia and the Serbian attack on Bosnia. All of his four accounts share certain key similarities. First, all the perpetrators were moved by a utopian ideology. Second, all the perpetrators were in some way or another "modern" and sought to use modern instruments to carry out their crimes. Third, all the genocides took place in periods of profound social and political crisis. Fourth, all the genocides were able to use the mass complicity of the society as a whole. Fifth, all the genocides had their own savage rituals of inhumanity.
Not bad, and the discussion of the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany are based on a reasonable discussion of the latest research. But there are some real problems with Weitz's account. For a start consider the "utopian" nature of genocide. Weitz does not define what a "utopia" is. This is rather important, since "utopian" implies the impossible, indeed the impossible that it would be dangerous to attempt. But while the Holocaust was a uniquely cruel atrocity, it was hardly "utopian" since it was, in fact, all too possible to kill 90% of Polish Jewry. More problematically, to what extent can Serbian nationalism be viewed as utopian? Undoubtedly some people thought a victorious Greater Serbia would lead to a better future. But the dominant themes in Serbian propaganda were paranoia, fear and self-pity. Instead of looking to a glorious millennium, Serbs concentrated on the "collective guilt" of Croats and Bosnians with Nazism. What Utopias did the Hutus dream of, or the final rulers of the Ottoman Empire have? One may agree with Weitz that Hitler and his colleagues believed in a "redemptive" anti-Semitism. But how far did this filter down to his executioners? (It strikes me that Arno Mayer's oft-derided "Why did the Heavens Not Darken," about the connection of the Holocaust to a vicious war against Communism, does better at answering this question.) The modernity of "genocide" is also problematic. That is certainly the case with Cambodia. Weitz's focus on ideology and ideological logic does not explain why Pol Pot followed a path that no other Communist party did. At one point Weitz suggests that Pol Pot's policies flowed logically from an ultra-radicalism, yet at other points he notes that he had to purge the Communist party frequently. More importantly, emptying the cities and abolishing money does not strike me as clever plans to destroy the ancien regime while following Democratic Kamuchea's own path to industrial modernity.
There are other problems. While genocide is understandably linked to war and crisis, this is not always the case. When destroying half of the population of what is now Congo, Belgium faced no imminent threat, nor did it carry out its crimes for any other reason than greed. Too much concentration on utopia and conflation of it with "fanaticism" leads to tautology. We condemn genocides as acts of fanaticism, and then define as fanatical genocidal acts. Weitz's discussion of the Yugoslav crisis does not really explain why so many Serbs and other Yugoslavs would support a policy that would definitely make the new nations considerably less than the sum of their parts. At one point Weitz mentions that Yugoslavia had a weaker civil society than, say, Poland or East Germany. But what distinguished pre-Milosevic Yugoslavia was not an especially brutal Communist regime. Indeed, the opposite was the case. Nor did Milosevic Serbia lack opposition parties and an independent church. There were no shortage of Serbs who denounced Milosevic, but a profound shortage of those who denounced Srebnica, and Weitz does not really explain why. At times Weitz's arguments are weak. He discusses popular complicity with genocidal crimes, though his main example for Nazi Germany actually takes place in Lithuania. He takes an example of one Serbian thug who comments that a victim looks like a cabbage and generalizes that this how all Serbian fighters viewed Bosnians. This is part of a larger problem with Weitz's discussion of ritual. Much of what he says about tortures and the rituals of atrocities is true, much of it is obvious, much of it is fashionable, but none of it is new or original. Likewise the accounts of genocide, while obviously horrific, do not really get us close to the minds of the perpetrators. Ultimately this is a book that adds little to our knowledge.
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful.
Holocausts
By John C. Landon
Interesting analytical comparative history of genocide in the twentieth century, in Russia, Germany, Cambodia, and Serbia. After invoking the case of Armenia the author shows the common core of these four in the light of the nineteenth century tide of race and nationalism. The emergence of race as a concept is demonized now, but the legacy of Darwinism tends to be underplayed, although the account makes clear the mood of Social Darwinist confusion leading up to the First World War and its coarsening of spirits (and Armenian overture) resulting in the walpurgisnacht to come. The concept of genocide was arguably miscast, since it applies too technically to racial issues. (Cf.The emergence of the term and the Genocide treaty, along with the life of its inventor Lemkin in A Problem from Hell. Also the case of Rwanda should be included, cf. A People Betrayed, by L. R. Melvern)
13 of 18 people found the following review helpful.
Skip it
By Michael B. Farrell
This book is poorly written, painfully repetitive, and excruciatingly poorly edited. The ideas are poorly organized, and at times it appears to be nothing more than a loose collection of quotations from other authors. The first chapter contains some interesting ideas, but its straight downhill from there. I should have known not to waste my time with this book when, in the prelude, the author states he will not address the Rwandan genocide because he doesn't know enough about it. Since the book attempts to cover the phenomenon of genocide in the 20th century from a comprehensive perspective, it seems somewhat dubious that the author submits not to understand one of the major genocides of the century. In short, this book is boring, obtuse and devoid of any useful purpose - I suggest taking a pass.
See all 8 customer reviews...
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz PDF
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz EPub
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz Doc
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz iBooks
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz rtf
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz Mobipocket
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz Kindle
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz PDF
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz PDF
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz PDF
A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation, by Eric D. Weitz PDF
